Subject: Wait! What about....
From: sandyv@ux1.cso.uiuc.edu (Sandra Vavrinek)
Date: 1990-09-18, 15:08
Newsgroups: alt.tv.twin-peaks

Okay! Okay!  I give in!  I'll post.  I've been content being a lurker, but
A couple things have been floating around in my mind and I thought I'd toss
them into the ring for discussion.

1.  Who says the killer has to be a "J" ?  Laura just said she was "nervous
about meeting 'J' tonight".  She didn't say she was worried that J would kill
her tonight.  Maybe she was killed before she met up with that particular 'J'? 
Maybe she met 'J' and all was well?  Maybe Bobby did it after all?

2.  Disregarding 1st question, do we all believe in the rock and bottle bit 
by Cooper because he is such an interesting character?  Or isn't it still
possible that blind luck caused certain bottles to be hit/broken, or that
the killer was never on the list, or that the rock hitting the bottle meant
something entirely different (don't ask me what - I'm just brainstorming) ?

3.  After 8 weeks of all this fabulous intuition and insight and reading
body language, Cooper (and this is my biggest disappointment) doesn't even
suspect that it was not Leo that called in the tip about James' bike or that,
especially because it was a "tip", that James was being framed.  Maybe it
was just my own mis-interpretation of the scene, but if others got the
same impression then:
Wouldn't the rock and bottle bit (question 2) be simple chance?
Couldn't he have been wrong about Bobby (question 1) NOT being the
killer?  see pilot "he didn't do it" to HST
Maybe etc ad infinitum.....


Please don't flame me!  I just rewatched the whole first series and my head 
is maybe in a whirlwind.  I picked up so many things the 2nd (okay, 3rd) time
through.  Just submitting for comment.


-- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ******************************************************************************* Sandra Vavrinek