Subject: Cooper Infallible?
From: andy@pangea.Stanford.EDU (Andy Michael USGS Guest)
Date: 1990-10-04, 19:39
Newsgroups: alt.tv.twin-peaks

At least one poster has referred to the idea that Cooper is
infallible (e.g. "I am not dreaming" implies that the Giant
is real.).  Is this true?  I can think of two things that seem
like mistakes to me:
1.  Coop wants to know who J is so he throws rocks at the Bottles.
    He comes up with Leo.  Now he thinks that J is James.  Of
    course you could argue that the rocks were answering a broader
    question like, "Who is the baddest on this list that didn't
    actually kill LP?"

2.  Coop says something like, "Find whoever has the other half
    of this heart and we'll know who the killer is."  Either
    James/Jacoby is the killer or the info about Jacoby finding
    the heart is a major clue.  But as one poster pointed out
    the whole heart thing seems innocent now.  Unless of course
    there are two hearts, one she shared with James and one she
    shared with BOB.

I dunno, but it seems like we can't trust everything Coop says,
although he is still one cool dude. -andy

Disclaimer: This is not the opinion of the FBI, or any other
government agency including any that I might work for.