Subject: Re: TRAINCAR EXPLANATION From: horny@ucscl.UCSC.EDU (Heather Vinopal) Date: 1990-11-09, 09:47 Newsgroups: alt.tv.twin-peaks In article <7959@ucdavis.ucdavis.edu> chiang@iris.ucdavis.edu (Tom Chiang) writes: > > > >...come on, that whole [traincar] scene is there for a reason: to try and shed > >some light on what happened at the traincar and what ronnette > >saw...BOB is clearly very angry or exultant...furthermore, he is > >pounding something...i think we can all accept that...now, if u think > >BOB killed her, then u think he was exultant and pounding her No. What if BOB was upset that he killed her? That Laura made him kill her? Or what if the host was upset that BOB made him do it? Killers aren't always happy that they had to kill, sometimes people are forced into killing, when they wish they didn't have to. These ideas aren't totally unfounded, Laura talked about a planned confrontation with BOB in the diary, perhaps a trade, a battle, or sacrificing herself. I'll follow this up at the bottom of the post. The only new idea in the "BLACK MAGIC" theory is that Laura, (paraphrased) "sacrificed herself to demons/owls before BOB could get her." (We've seen the idea that Laura sacrificed herself to BOB or forced him to kill her before). Who is the third man Laura had sex with? Whose blood was found at the traincar? It wasn't owl or demon blood, nor owl or demon semen. :) Police established that there was a third man at the traincar, who was it? Laura hit Ronette with a hammer? Ronette indicates BOB did. I suppose Ronette could have been hit by BOB after Laura sacrificed herself, but I think she was hit early on in the traincar scene. A demon or owl used a hammer? Or do you think Laura brought the hammer? BOB wasn't around when Laura was still alive, as implied by Ronette's vision? If Laura was planning on sacrificing herself, why did she expose her good friend Ronette to that hell? Someone tied up Laura at the traincar, do you think Ronette did it? Where did Laura learn how to sacrifice herself to owls and demons? Why would these evil creatures cooperate in Laura's plan to frustrate their buddy BOB? I think BOB killed Laura via a human host-- Leland, or less likely Ben. I don't know exactly why BOB killed her, but I definately think Laura's actions had something to do with when and why she was killed. Really hokey ideas follow. *Many of these are similiar and overlap...* These ideas mostly come from my reading of the diary. The quotes are my own. 1) Laura felt that something she did that night could get rid of BOB. Some kind of exorcism. Whoops! Maybe it worked, but it cost her life. 2) Laura made a trade deal with BOB to get rid of him. Perhaps BOB is hanging out in Ronette or Maddy now. "Let me die!" "FIND ME A VICTIM TO TAKE YOUR PLACE" "Sure! Is Ronette cute enough?" (see pg 85 + 175 of the diary to learn more about a possible trade w/BOB) 3) Laura couldn't take BOB anymore, and forced BOB to kill her. BOB normally would't let Laura kill herself, but Laura found a way to make BOB do it. "Hey BOB, if you don't kill me, I will make your existance totally unfun. We both know you are eager for fun. I also know who and what you are and will tell everyone." 4) Laura couldn't take BOB anymore. She finally discovered a weakness in BOB, a way to really hurt him, and confronted him with it that night. She hoped it would have really harmed or killed BOB, but instead BOB was forced to kill her in self defense. Perhaps Laura did succeed in screwing BOB over to some degree, anyway. 5) Laura didn't find a way to harm BOB, but she did discover a way to really piss him off. BOB killed Laura, to stop her pissing him off. Similar to #3, without the desire to die. "hey BOB, you are unclean, not me. I know how to make your life very unpleasant and I will. Revenge is sweet" 6) BOB killed Laura, as had been planned by him for years. The experiment was over. Nexxxxt. (Theresa, then Laura, then who?) 7) Laura knew too much about him, as stated on the last page of the diary. BOB killed a potential threat. Laura didn't want to die, and didn't directly threaten BOB with her knowledge as in #3. that's enough for now. Michael Kaye horny@ucscb.ucsc.edu "BOB needs a human host for his gameshow"