Subject: Re: What Happened in the Black Lodge
From: srt@aero.org (Scott "TCB" Turner)
Date: 1991-06-14, 09:53
Newsgroups: alt.tv.twin-peaks

Why believe what BOB says in the Black Lodge to Coop?  Perhaps WE did
have some mastery of the power of the Black Lodge and took Coop's 
soul.  Then when BOB took WE, he inherited Coop's soul and was able
to create from it the Coopelganger.

This whole theory works a bit better if what WE took from Coop was the
dark side of Coop's nature (I like that evil can only have power over
evil).  However, if this is the case I think it will require a 
transporter effect to re-unite the two sides of Kirk's (I mean Coop's)
soul.

-- Scott Turner